Tuesday, April 13, 2021
Chinese (Simplified)EnglishFrenchGermanItalianJapanesePortugueseRussianSpanish
Contact
No Result
View All Result
FuturoProssimo
  • Home
  • Tech
  • Medicine
  • Society
  • Ambience
  • Spazio
  • Transportation
  • concepts
  • H+
FuturoProssimo
No Result
View All Result

Coronavirus News »

Chinese (Simplified)EnglishFrenchGermanItalianJapanesePortugueseRussianSpanish

Clubhouse grows explosively, but security is creepy

Clubhouse has boomed, but there are many doubts about the security and privacy of this app. What are the current problems? Here is a complete map.

Gianluca Ricciodi Gianluca Riccio
March 1 2021
in Technology
clubhouse
Send to FacebookPin on PinterestSend on TwitterSend on Whatsappon Linkedin

In just over a few months, Clubhouse, the audio-based social media app, has emerged in a disruptive fashion. Its format seems familiar: a bit twitter, a bit linkedin, a bit phone call to Aunt Concetta. Can you talk about and with everyone: a chat about inspiration with your favorite singer? A nice conversation with half the radio world, comparisons on politics with the most famous pollsters? A bar where many differences break down.

The expansion of Clubhouse, however, dramatically shows the security and privacy deficiencies of this app: they will force the company to run for cover very soon.

Clubhouse is still in beta and only available on iOS for invitations. Until recently he had only ONE room. Today it offers its users the possibility of creating them at will: it is essentially group audio chats. They can be interactive, with a moderator who "calls" from time to time people to talk and converse, or one-way. According to reported, Clubhouse has over 10 millions of users and a value that already exceeds a billion dollars. The still relatively elitist character of the app causes several celebrities to populate the rooms, creating a curious mix of entertainment and friendly conversation. What could go wrong?

Maybe you are also interested

Clubhouse launched social audio, but now it has to fight for life

Victor Glushkov, the man who anticipated the internet and the failed Soviet future

When the app flops: 3 forgotten online innovations

Internet speed in Italy: growing everywhere! Here is the data region by region

Clubhouse and privacy
A "revived" (in reality he never died) and free range Red Ronnie, one of the most pleasant users to listen to on Clubhouse

Security, amigo

Clubhouse has an Achilles heel as big as a house: affects the amount of privacy that its users should expect, and in general the security of the entire system. When you experience such growth, everything increases: the level of exposure, the threats, the number of people “probing” the platform to steal data.

One of the researchers who studied Clubhouse's possible data passes explains that the app doesn't have anti-scraping mechanisms. That is, Clubhouse does not have a "shield" against those who want to take conversations, even from multiple rooms, and transmit them elsewhere. Or record and save them for analysis.

Stanford's Clubhouse Safety Analysis

Recent Clubhouse-related security issues range from general vulnerabilities to infrastructure questions. Just over a week ago, researchers from the Stanford Internet Observatory i have aimed spotlights on the platform when they found that the app was broadcasting Clubhouse user IDs in an unencrypted way, meaning a third party could potentially track users' actions in the app. The researchers further pointed out that part of the Clubhouse infrastructure is managed by a Shanghai-based company and it appeared that the app's data had been traveling across China for at least some time, potentially exposing users to surveillance. targeted or even widespread Chinese government. 

Then came the confirmation a week ago: Bloomberg has confirmed that a third party website was collecting and compiling audio from Clubhouse conversations. Earlier on Monday, further revelations followed that conversations in the Clubhouse had been tapped from an unaffiliated Android app , allowing users of that operating system to hear what was being said in real time.

More mature social networks like Facebook have more developed mechanisms to block their data, both to prevent violations of user privacy and to defend the data they hold as an asset. But even they may still have potential exposures from scraping techniques creative .

The Clubhouse itself was analyzed for its aptitude to encourage the sharing of user directory data. The app requires you to share your contact list to invite other people on the platform, being the invitation system. This helps create a sense of exclusivity and privacy, sure, but many users have pointed out that the app also provides suggestions based on which phone numbers in your contacts are also in the contacts of the most Clubhouse users. In other words, if you and your friends all use the same florist, doctor (or drug dealer), they could very well show up on your recommended invite list.

From Clubhouse comes a No Comment. For how long?

Clubhouse did not respond to requests made by several outlets to comment on its recent security issues. It detailed the specific changes it intends to make, including cutting passages on Chinese servers and tightening its encryption. A little further on this: generic "guarantees" to prevent problems from occurring (or repeating). There is still a feeling that Clubhouse hasn't thought properly about its safety, in short. 

Clubhouse
Alberto Ferrarini, mental coach of Bonucci and other footballers and sportsmen, another user who holds the bench in the long conversations of the Italian Clubhouse

And we haven't considered privacy yet

When starting a new Clubhouse room, you can choose between three settings: a room "open" to any user, a "social" room open only to the people you follow and a "closed" room with limited access. Each has its own (implicit) level of privacy, which Clubhouse could make more explicit.

"I think for public rooms, Clubhouse should better understand that 'public' means public for all users, since anyone can participate and register, take notes, etc." David Thiel, chief technology officer of the Stanford Internet Observatory. "For private rooms, they can communicate that, as with any communication mechanism, an authorized member can record content and identity."

And the abuses?

Like any major social network, Clubhouse also has to cope the abuses on its platform. The app's terms of service prohibit hate speech, racism and harassment (a starting from November) and the platform offers some moderation features. You can block users, or report them, or report an entire room. The biggest problem with Clubhouse, however, is general: people can use the platform without the responsibility that their content is saved. Apparently, in short (apparently) verba volant. This may encourage some users to make offensive or derogatory comments, in the belief that they are not registered and therefore not face consequences.

One of the "stages" visited in the Clubhouse

But is it really so?

Stanford's Thiel says Clubhouse currently temporarily stores recordings of discussions. In case they can be used for reports of abuse. And this is a snake biting its own tail. Why? If it introduces (as required) end-to-end encryption for data security, it will have a harder time logging. If he has trouble recording, he will have a hard time fighting abuse. Abuse, privacy, data security are interconnected: it will not be easy to make ends meet.

Again: even with encryption, the possibility of any Clubhouse user recording conversations on his own is not eliminated. And that's not something Clubhouse can easily fix.

However, and this must do so as soon as possible, Clubhouse can be transparent about these things, informing users on the conduct to be held. Because Clubhouse looks like that friendly bar where you can suddenly meet a celebrity, but of course it is NOT an intimate and confined place. And it pays to know how to speak and what to say.

Anyway, net of these (not just) security problems, it is a social network that really has a lot of charm. And in fact, with all the precautions and the education of the case I have sled there. If you are there too and want to chat with me, look for Gianluca Riccio on Clubhouse.

We talk about it there too! But "watch out" what you say, huh :)

tags: clubhouseInternetprivacy
Previous post

M1, the huge 165-inch MicroLED TV vanishes into thin air when turned off

Next article

For the planet, the electric car is better than the traditional car, isn't it?

Collaborate!

We are open to visions about the future. Submit an article, disclose the results of a search or scientific discoveries, shows points of view on a theme, tells about a change.

Contact us

Most read of the week

  • CoroNaspresso, Covid tests at home are studied in coffee capsules

    CoroNaspresso, Covid tests at home are studied in coffee capsules

    74 shares
    Share 29 Tweet 18
  • US intelligence analyzes the future, and it doesn't look good at all

    70 shares
    Share 28 Tweet 17
  • CNN: Russia tests a weapon that creates "radioactive Tsunamis"

    65 shares
    Share 26 Tweet 16
  • Physicists at Microsoft think the universe is a self-taught computer

    52 shares
    Share 20 Tweet 13
The last
Technology

The structure of a spider's web is translated into music

Technology

CalTech uses underwater cables to detect earthquakes and tsunamis in advance

Ambience

The rising of the sea is unstoppable. You need to think big

Ambience

Plants that “exude” metal: can agromining replace mines?

archive

Next article
Electric car is better than the traditional one

For the planet, the electric car is better than the traditional car, isn't it?

A team reprograms the cartilage that produces its own anti-inflammatories

A team reprograms the cartilage that produces its own anti-inflammatories

Facebook

Instagram

Telegram

Twitter

Clubhouse

Near future

Futuroprossimo.it is an Italian futurology resource open since 2006: every day news about the near future. Scientific discoveries, medical research, prototypes, concepts and predictions about the future for free.

Tag

Ambience Architecture Club Communication concepts Advice Economy Energy Events Gadgets The future of yesterday The newspaper of tomorrow Italy Next Medicine Military Weather Robotica Society Spazio Technology transhumanism Transportation Video

The author

Gianluca Riccio, copywriter and journalist - Born in 1975, he is the creative director of an advertising agency, he is affiliated with the Italian Institute for the Future, World Future Society and H +, Network of Italian Transhumanists.

Home / Author / IDEA / archive / Promo on FP

Collaborate! Are you interested in writing a post on Futuroprossimo? Click here for contacts.

Categories

Creative Commons License
This work is distributed under license Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International.
© 2021 Futuroprossimo

  • Home
  • Contact
  • archive
  • Technology
  • Medicine
  • Transportation
  • Weather
  • Society
  • Ambience
  • transhumanism

© 2021 Futuroprossimo - Creative Commons License
This work is distributed under license Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International.

This site uses cookies. By continuing to read it, you consent to their use.